index.html (13902B)
1 <!DOCTYPE html> 2 <html lang="en"> 3 4 <head> 5 <title> 6 Self-Ownership and the Logic of Property · Jack Mordaunt 7 </title> 8 <meta charset="utf-8"> 9 <meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width, initial-scale=1.0"> 10 <meta name="color-scheme" content="light dark"> 11 12 13 14 15 <meta name="author" content="Jack Mordaunt"> 16 <meta name="description" content="Self-ownership is the natural ownership of the exclusive handle of one’s body, from which all property and morality derive."> 17 <meta name="keywords" content="blog,developer,personal,software,robust,performance,sovereign"> 18 19 20 21 <meta name="twitter:card" content="summary"> 22 <meta name="twitter:title" content="Self-Ownership and the Logic of Property"> 23 <meta name="twitter:description" content="Self-ownership is the natural ownership of the exclusive handle of one’s body, from which all property and morality derive."> 24 25 <meta property="og:url" content="http://jackmordaunt.com/posts/self-ownership/"> 26 <meta property="og:site_name" content="Jack Mordaunt"> 27 <meta property="og:title" content="Self-Ownership and the Logic of Property"> 28 <meta property="og:description" content="Self-ownership is the natural ownership of the exclusive handle of one’s body, from which all property and morality derive."> 29 <meta property="og:locale" content="en"> 30 <meta property="og:type" content="article"> 31 <meta property="article:section" content="posts"> 32 <meta property="article:published_time" content="2025-09-23T19:03:55-03:00"> 33 <meta property="article:modified_time" content="2025-09-23T19:03:55-03:00"> 34 35 36 37 38 <link rel="canonical" href="http://jackmordaunt.com/posts/self-ownership/"> 39 40 41 <link rel="preload" href="/fonts/fa-brands-400.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin> 42 <link rel="preload" href="/fonts/fa-regular-400.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin> 43 <link rel="preload" href="/fonts/fa-solid-900.woff2" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin> 44 45 46 47 48 <link rel="stylesheet" href="/css/coder.min.6445a802b9389c9660e1b07b724dcf5718b1065ed2d71b4eeaf981cc7cc5fc46.css" integrity="sha256-ZEWoArk4nJZg4bB7ck3PVxixBl7S1xtO6vmBzHzF/EY=" crossorigin="anonymous" media="screen" /> 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 <link rel="stylesheet" href="/css/coder-dark.min.a00e6364bacbc8266ad1cc81230774a1397198f8cfb7bcba29b7d6fcb54ce57f.css" integrity="sha256-oA5jZLrLyCZq0cyBIwd0oTlxmPjPt7y6KbfW/LVM5X8=" crossorigin="anonymous" media="screen" /> 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 <link rel="stylesheet" href="/css/custom.min.931a9d02d6f7655cd0cd50317fac1204e00c54ffd0232085acc957b2db5e1283.css" integrity="sha256-kxqdAtb3ZVzQzVAxf6wSBOAMVP/QIyCFrMlXstteEoM=" crossorigin="anonymous" media="screen" /> 67 68 69 70 71 72 73 <link rel="icon" type="image/svg+xml" href="/images/self-tiny-white.svg" sizes="any"> 74 <link rel="icon" type="image/png" href="/images/self-tiny-white.png" sizes="32x32"> 75 <link rel="icon" type="image/png" href="/images/self-tiny-white.png" sizes="16x16"> 76 77 <link rel="apple-touch-icon" href="/images/apple-touch-icon.png"> 78 <link rel="apple-touch-icon" sizes="180x180" href="/images/apple-touch-icon.png"> 79 80 <link rel="manifest" href="/site.webmanifest"> 81 <link rel="mask-icon" href="/images/safari-pinned-tab.svg" color="#5bbad5"> 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 <script defer data-domain="jackmordaunt.com" src="https://plausible.io/js/script.js"></script> 90 91 92 93 94 </head> 95 96 97 98 99 100 101 <body class="preload-transitions colorscheme-auto"> 102 103 <div class="float-container"> 104 <a id="dark-mode-toggle" class="colorscheme-toggle"> 105 <i class="fa-solid fa-adjust fa-fw" aria-hidden="true"></i> 106 </a> 107 </div> 108 109 110 <main class="wrapper"> 111 <nav class="navigation"> 112 <section class="container"> 113 114 <a class="navigation-title" href="http://jackmordaunt.com/"> 115 Jack Mordaunt 116 </a> 117 118 119 <input type="checkbox" id="menu-toggle" /> 120 <label class="menu-button float-right" for="menu-toggle"> 121 <i class="fa-solid fa-bars fa-fw" aria-hidden="true"></i> 122 </label> 123 <ul class="navigation-list"> 124 125 126 <li class="navigation-item"> 127 <a class="navigation-link " href="/posts/">Blog</a> 128 </li> 129 130 <li class="navigation-item"> 131 <a class="navigation-link " href="/about/">About</a> 132 </li> 133 134 <li class="navigation-item"> 135 <a class="navigation-link " href="/projects/">Projects</a> 136 </li> 137 138 <li class="navigation-item"> 139 <a class="navigation-link " href="/contact/">Contact</a> 140 </li> 141 142 <li class="navigation-item"> 143 <a class="navigation-link " href="/pay-with-bitcoin/">Pay</a> 144 </li> 145 146 147 148 </ul> 149 150 </section> 151 </nav> 152 153 154 <div class="content"> 155 156 <section class="container post"> 157 <article> 158 <header> 159 <div class="post-title"> 160 <h1 class="title"> 161 <a class="title-link" href="http://jackmordaunt.com/posts/self-ownership/"> 162 Self-Ownership and the Logic of Property 163 </a> 164 </h1> 165 </div> 166 <div class="post-meta"> 167 <div class="date"> 168 <span class="posted-on"> 169 <i class="fa-solid fa-calendar" aria-hidden="true"></i> 170 <time datetime="2025-09-23T19:03:55-03:00"> 171 September 23, 2025 172 </time> 173 </span> 174 <span class="reading-time"> 175 <i class="fa-solid fa-clock" aria-hidden="true"></i> 176 4-minute read 177 </span> 178 </div> 179 180 <div class="categories"> 181 <i class="fa-solid fa-folder" aria-hidden="true"></i> 182 <a href="/categories/philosophy/">Philosophy</a></div> 183 184 185 </div> 186 </header> 187 188 <div class="post-content"> 189 190 <h1 id="self-ownership-and-the-logic-of-property"> 191 <strong>Self-Ownership and the Logic of Property</strong> 192 <a class="heading-link" href="#self-ownership-and-the-logic-of-property"> 193 <i class="fa-solid fa-link" aria-hidden="true" title="Link to heading"></i> 194 <span class="sr-only">Link to heading</span> 195 </a> 196 </h1> 197 <p><strong>Self-ownership = the exclusive handle over your body, with a custody chain that terminates in you and no one else.</strong></p> 198 <hr> 199 <h2 id="introduction"> 200 <strong>Introduction</strong> 201 <a class="heading-link" href="#introduction"> 202 <i class="fa-solid fa-link" aria-hidden="true" title="Link to heading"></i> 203 <span class="sr-only">Link to heading</span> 204 </a> 205 </h2> 206 <p>The Non-Aggression Principle (NAP) is usually built on the axiom of self-ownership: the claim that one owns oneself and the results of one’s actions.</p> 207 <p>Locke, Hoppe, and Rothbard approximate this concept, treating it as “self-evident” within natural law or libertarian ethics. But critics often challenge the axiom as unfounded or subjective. If self-ownership cannot be demonstrated, then aggression—the coercive seizure of others’ bodies or property—can be reframed as morally permissible.</p> 208 <p>This essay proposes a way to <strong>derive</strong> self-ownership from objective facts about scarcity, exclusivity, and custody. The goal is to show that self-ownership is not a bare axiom but the <em>base case</em> of property rights.</p> 209 <hr> 210 <h2 id="exclusivity"> 211 <strong>Exclusivity</strong> 212 <a class="heading-link" href="#exclusivity"> 213 <i class="fa-solid fa-link" aria-hidden="true" title="Link to heading"></i> 214 <span class="sr-only">Link to heading</span> 215 </a> 216 </h2> 217 <p>All resources are finite. A resource is <em>scarce</em> when it is finite relative to human desire, such that competing claims can plausibly arise.</p> 218 <ul> 219 <li> 220 <p><strong>Consumables:</strong> Air molecules metabolized in lungs; food broken into bodily tissue.</p> 221 </li> 222 <li> 223 <p><strong>Durables:</strong> Tools, land, and vehicles that can be controlled but not consumed.</p> 224 </li> 225 </ul> 226 <p>Every scarce resource terminates in a <strong>point of exclusive control or consumption</strong>. Call this a <strong>resource handle</strong>.</p> 227 <ul> 228 <li> 229 <p>Only one person can eat a given apple.</p> 230 </li> 231 <li> 232 <p>Only one person can operate a particular plow at a time.</p> 233 </li> 234 <li> 235 <p>Even abundant goods (like air) can become scarce in special contexts (diving, Mars colonies).</p> 236 </li> 237 </ul> 238 <p><strong>Handles are mutually exclusive.</strong> Control or consumption by one agent excludes simultaneous use by others.</p> 239 <hr> 240 <h2 id="ownership"> 241 <strong>Ownership</strong> 242 <a class="heading-link" href="#ownership"> 243 <i class="fa-solid fa-link" aria-hidden="true" title="Link to heading"></i> 244 <span class="sr-only">Link to heading</span> 245 </a> 246 </h2> 247 <p>Exclusivity alone is not enough. <strong>Ownership = exclusive custody of a handle + a valid chain of custody.</strong></p> 248 <ul> 249 <li> 250 <p><strong>Custody</strong> is descriptive: who currently controls or consumes the resource.</p> 251 </li> 252 <li> 253 <p><strong>Validity</strong> is normative: whether the transfer of the handle followed accepted rules.</p> 254 </li> 255 </ul> 256 <p>Example:</p> 257 <ul> 258 <li> 259 <p>If you steal an apple from a vendor and eat it, you hold the handle (consumption), but you broke the rule of voluntary exchange.</p> 260 </li> 261 <li> 262 <p>If you pay for the apple, the transfer is valid, and ownership passes.</p> 263 </li> 264 </ul> 265 <p>A <strong>chain of custody</strong> is the sequence of valid transfers. Ownership means not only holding the handle but also being connected to this chain. Theft = handle without chain.</p> 266 <p>Rules of validity are normative, shaped by incentives and consensus. Most societies converge on the rule that <em>voluntary exchange = valid</em>. Charity is another rule: transfer without payment but with consent. A rule that “all seizures are valid” would destroy incentives and collapse into chaos.</p> 267 <hr> 268 <h2 id="homesteading"> 269 <strong>Homesteading</strong> 270 <a class="heading-link" href="#homesteading"> 271 <i class="fa-solid fa-link" aria-hidden="true" title="Link to heading"></i> 272 <span class="sr-only">Link to heading</span> 273 </a> 274 </h2> 275 <p>Where do custody chains begin?</p> 276 <ul> 277 <li> 278 <p><strong>Unowned resources</strong>: no one holds the handle.</p> 279 </li> 280 <li> 281 <p><strong>Homesteading</strong>: the first agent to establish control (picking a wild apple, farming land, mining ore) creates the first custody link.</p> 282 </li> 283 </ul> 284 <p>This bootstrap event grounds legitimacy. Subsequent transfers extend the chain. Theft interrupts it.</p> 285 <p>Thus homesteading is the origin of all property outside the self.</p> 286 <hr> 287 <h2 id="the-algebra-of-self-ownership"> 288 <strong>The Algebra of Self-Ownership</strong> 289 <a class="heading-link" href="#the-algebra-of-self-ownership"> 290 <i class="fa-solid fa-link" aria-hidden="true" title="Link to heading"></i> 291 <span class="sr-only">Link to heading</span> 292 </a> 293 </h2> 294 <p>General rule:</p> 295 <p><strong>Ownership = exclusive handle + valid custody chain.</strong></p> 296 <p>But what about the self?</p> 297 <ul> 298 <li> 299 <p>Your body is a scarce resource.</p> 300 </li> 301 <li> 302 <p>You hold its exclusive handle through your agency.</p> 303 </li> 304 <li> 305 <p>Unlike external resources, your agency is non-transferable: no one else can <em>be</em> you or assume direct control of your neurons.</p> 306 </li> 307 </ul> 308 <p>Thus the custody chain of the self is unique: it begins and ends within the individual. There is no prior custodian and no possibility of transfer.</p> 309 <p>This makes self-ownership a <strong>special case</strong> where the normative component drops out. Exclusivity alone suffices because nature itself validates the chain. No opinion, law, or consensus can alter the brute fact that your agency is yours.</p> 310 <hr> 311 <h2 id="conclusion"> 312 <strong>Conclusion</strong> 313 <a class="heading-link" href="#conclusion"> 314 <i class="fa-solid fa-link" aria-hidden="true" title="Link to heading"></i> 315 <span class="sr-only">Link to heading</span> 316 </a> 317 </h2> 318 <ul> 319 <li> 320 <p>Scarce resources terminate in exclusive handles.</p> 321 </li> 322 <li> 323 <p>Ownership arises when exclusive custody is connected to a valid custody chain.</p> 324 </li> 325 <li> 326 <p>Homesteading begins the chain for unowned resources.</p> 327 </li> 328 <li> 329 <p>In the special case of the self, the chain terminates within the individual, non-transferable by nature.</p> 330 </li> 331 </ul> 332 <p>Therefore: <strong>self-ownership is not an assumption but a demonstrable fact.</strong></p> 333 <p>The NAP then follows as a corollary: aggression is the illegitimate seizure of another’s handle, whether of their body or their external property.</p> 334 <p>This framework reframes morality as property logic: violations of morality are violations of ownership. Ethics extends to how we use our own handles responsibly in community. Aesthetics orders the abundant signals that shape recognition and valuation of custody chains. And political philosophy becomes the theory of how societies manage handles at scale.</p> 335 <p>Self-ownership, then, is the first custody chain—the foundation on which every system of rights, trade, and cooperation must rest.</p> 336 337 </div> 338 339 340 <footer> 341 342 343 <section class="see-also"> 344 345 346 347 348 349 </section> 350 351 352 353 354 355 356 357 358 359 </footer> 360 </article> 361 362 363 </section> 364 365 </div> 366 367 <footer class="footer"> 368 <section class="container"> 369 © 370 371 2025 372 Jack Mordaunt 373 · 374 375 Powered by <a href="https://gohugo.io/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Hugo</a> & <a href="https://github.com/luizdepra/hugo-coder/" target="_blank" rel="noopener">Coder</a>. 376 377 </section> 378 </footer> 379 380 </main> 381 382 383 384 385 386 <script src="/js/coder.min.6ae284be93d2d19dad1f02b0039508d9aab3180a12a06dcc71b0b0ef7825a317.js" integrity="sha256-auKEvpPS0Z2tHwKwA5UI2aqzGAoSoG3McbCw73gloxc="></script> 387 388 389 390 391 392 393 394 395 396 397 398 399 400 401 402 403 404 405 406 407 408 409 410 411 412 413 414 415 416 417 418 419 420 421 422 423 424 425 426 427 </body> 428 </html>